A phrase denoting simplicity. An open and shut proposition is one which must be accepted or rejected in its entirety.
1848. That chaps snoring beat all the high-pressures he ever heerdjest as easy as open and shet!Durivage and Burnham, Stray Subjects, p. 128.
1902. I lowed we was going to make an open-and-shut trade that we could be proud of.W. N. Harben, Abner Daniel, p. 153.